What is Psychogeography? with Iain Sinclair

This is a live audio recording plus transcript of me and Iain Sinclair answering an audience question of What Is Psychogeography at the Wanstead Tap, May 2024.

Could you both please try and define psychogeography?

Iain Sinclair:

Now, John,

John Rogers:

You can’t be sat here with Iain Sinclair the one person you think can answer that question? I’ll tell you what I’m going to do Iain. I’m going to I’m going to hand this. I’m going to I’m going to find a point to hand it back to you. So Psychogeography, as I understood it In a way is two things, there is the classical definition of it, which is developed by a guy who’s kind of been written out of history a little bit Ivan Chtcheglov Or Gilles Ivain who was a very precocious young man, but there were a group of French pseudo intellectuals who become French intellectuals, were very interested in town planning and architecture And they hated modernism and they hated the surrealists. And so they thought cities were constraining the human spirit. They put a lot of effort into coming up with an alternative vision of cities. But in a lot of ways, I think what’s often missed out of that version of Psychogeography an important distinction to make, is they were revolutionaries. They believed in political revolution. They didn’t just but part of that was this revolution of everyday life. So a lot of ways their dérives, which apparently from people that weren’t one of the little group, is that they were kind of like they were very short and they often involved red wine and cigarettes and they were reconnaissance missions for a revolution that they hoped would one day come. And it very nearly did. Guy Debord was a big inspiration for the movement in May ’68 when they nearly overthrew the French government. So it was part of a political programme which saw the city as the primary kind of battle ground for where the revolution would take place, and of which this wandering around of it was. and making artworks The rest of it was part of it. But they were they were political animals and they operated like a political cadre, you know, the list in the Situationist International. A friend of mine’s got almost the complete library of all the little texts that they put out. And there is a document with all the members and it’s just literally ‘date joined’ ‘date expelled’, apart from an English guy who left Charles Radcliffe, who actually is the only person I think, to resign from the Situationist International. About a thousand people were members. All of them were expelled by Debord. But then those ideas get translated badly, by Chris Gray. Into a book called Leaving the 20th Century arrives in the UK, some hippies from Hackney who had an interest in stone circles and Earth mysteries. Pick it up Over to you Iain, the most influential. The reason you’re asking that question is probably because of what Iain (Sinclair) did next.

Iain Sinclair:

Dear God You know, I should have listened to John’s answer before I get asked this quite a lot and I’m aware of the original group. I as a kind of in a very standard French philosophical tradition. I mean it’s just like I know they despise the surrealists in some ways, but they behave exactly like them. It was like with André Breton instead of Guy Debord They expel each other as you describe. They have a kind of philosophical vision which all disagree about, and then they go out and get drunk and that whole thing. And it’s quite interesting just to everything feeds back to Hackney with me. But there’s a there’s a film Orson Welles Made, Around the World with Orson Welles, which has a beautiful sequence outside Hackney Empire Theatre, where he’s rehearsing Moby Dick, and he comes out with cameras and he talks to these old ladies who live in Alms houses at the back, and they proudly say, “we’re all staunch Tories here”, which is great. And then it flips to Orson Welles is in Paris and he interviews some of the Letterists who are connected with the psychogeographers. And these poets sort of read quite abstruse conceptual poems in a bookshop, and they all look incredibly bourgeois. You know, they are respectable students who are doing a sort of revolutionary thing as a form of philosophy. So I was aware of all that in the sixties to a degree. And didn’t really think so much about it. And, and when when the big meetings in the sixties, like the Dialectics of Liberation at the Roundhouse were going on, most of the luminaries there talked a lot about psycho politics. You know, R.D Laing and the anti psychiatrists here were very engaged with this. The psycho aspect was there as if there was something more revolutionary behind the standard tactics of politics. And it wasn’t really until people like Stewart Home started to publish cod Psychogeography in the Thatcher period in which they they pastiche a lot of the stuff, the classic psychogeography from Paris and added into elements of this other form which you’d mentioned of the Hackney Hippies of interest in stone circles and Avebury and landscape and that kind of energy lines or whatever. Also that that aspect had a social and political critique built into it. It wasn’t just about sort of goofy stuff. It was about the fact that what was going on in politics was it was a sort of form of occult energy. So so it was a it was a big energy debate. And combining the two forms came up with a brand. And I think then subsequently it became very diminished as a concept, though the revolutionary aspect was gone. But there was a sense of what, you know, wandering at wandering about cities in some vague way, taking snapshots and keeping journals was called Psychogeography. And I don’t think, you know, it is in any sense either in the classic sense or as in the secondary sense, which was also revolutionary in a small way, in a different way, but equally political,

John Rogers:

I think what you did come up with, though, is quite deeply political, actually. And I think because there’s an interesting shared lineage between because if the Situationist International reacting to the surrealists whilst also being very much inspired by them. At the same time, you have and they were and the surrealists were inspired by English romantics who are also interested in other things that you’re interested in, that there’s a very direct shared lineage with the English Romantics and people. De Quincey and and others, you know, also because they were also mashed on opium and kind of having visions. But then also at the same time, in the twenties, you had the English topographers who were writing about the new cities, the expansion of London, for example, and they were critiquing it, but they were critiquing it for I guess they were commissioned to write quite standard walking guides for the readers of the Sunday papers. But within it is a critique of road building of suburban sprawl and all the rest of it. And I think but they were also talking about, you know, people like SP Mais are talkingabout the bucolic nature of England. They’re also talking about, not earth mysteries, but the kind of topography of England. And so I do think there is a lot more and your template was a great template for resisting the nature of modern urban change, whereas the situationsts kind of took it on head first and actually wanted to build cities. They actually thought they were coming up with plans that could be actualized. Some of them were architects, whereas I think your vision was a lot more of a powerful tool for people to, to contest the vision that was being presented.

Ivan Chtcheglov psychogeography quote

Iain Sinclair:

Yeah, And I think one interesting crossover here is somebody who was photographed by John Deakin one of the key poets young poets, was published by David Archer’s Parton Press, David Gascoigne. David Gascoigne started publishing stuff in his teens and he’s one of the few of that group that I knew quite well. And he he became involved with the surrealists and he published one of the first English published primers to Surrealism, but he totally reengaged with his second division, PSYCHOGEOGRAPHY that was emerging. And he got in touch with me and he started to talk about the walks that he had done in London in a sort of psychogeographical sense, in that he was trying to tap into echoes of Rimbaud when he was in London and Rimbaud responding to the spirit of the city as a as a new sort of almost demonic entity of these the railway stations, the trains, the energy, and and it was achievable by going off on these amazing walks. And Gascoigne had gone backwards and forwards between Paris and London, translated a lot of that until he had a complete mental breakdown and sort of marched to the Elysee Palace. He to Buckingham Palace to say that he had the answer and they locked him up and he spent years in a hospital on the you know, on the Isle of Wight and then had an astonishing late life recovery. But his his travels between Psychogeography surrealism and political vision were interesting. In the very same time that he was engaged with surrealism, he was also on Cable Street he was on the march against when Mosley was marching into the East End. David Gascoigne was there as a witness, but as a kind of poetic witness. He was trying to read these things in terms of the poetry of the city, not just in the way that a lot of his his colleagues were mass observation reporters who were trying to sort of look at the working classes as if they were under a microscope. Gascoigne didn’t really do that. He gave himself up entirely to it. So he was a he was an inspiration for me, and I think he thought of himself strangely, as well as being an early surrealist, as being a late psychogeographer

John Rogers:

The Gravel Pit. Also really good resources online Houseman’s bookshop, they recorded the Charles Radcliffe talk. It was the first Chris Gray Memorial lecture and Charles Radcliffe was a schoolfriend of Chris Gray, and they went to Paris together to meet the Situationists and hung out with them for a bit. And that’s when Charles Radcliffe’s reaction was they were really square, you know. So he joined and then quit and that lecture’s really good. But that night I was there Houseman’s Stewart Home was there, as was Fabian Tompsett and I went up to Stewart and he goes, Oh yeah, meet Fabian, you know, Fabian’s the guy that actually started the London Psychogeographical Association newsletter paper. No, no, no, no. Stewart can keep that one there. But that’s just because of Iain Sinclair, if Iain hadn’t said that you know, it’s not me, it’s Fabian. Of course, in the spirit of those things. Fabian says No, no, no, no. It has to be Stewart, you know, I mean,

Iain Sinclair:

you know how just to turn it round the, the, a lot of the books and the films you’ve done are in the spirit, you know, understanding the original spirit and understanding the whole arc of it. Do you think Psychogeography is of importance to the way that, you know, you strike out from your home base or walks through the forest or the kind of backways of the city Some things obviously are a kind of interrogation. Others are just to do with with literally being out there and walking and seeing what comes less consciously now, I think I think now it’s just whatever comes through.

John Rogers:

But I think I don’t know how many years, I mean, sort of over years of reading about it and studying it. I think I guess it does kind of happen through osmosis now rather than consciously doing, you know, I did projects years ago where we used the tool we used as a tool to critique, a development, a town center redevelopment, and it gave us tools for public engagement as well because, you know, you need when you’re dealing with developers and planners, they’ve got their metrics. How do you respond? You know, what can you respond with? And so Psychogeography was a really useful set of tools to almost create data

Iain Sinclair:

does it need to be called something else like Nick Papadimitriou, you’ve done a lot with talks about deep topography and that is a is a very different thing, even though it has elements that in a sense the general terminology is so threadbare, if you just throw it in, which has become a kind of shorthand for all sorts of things and do we need to revolutionize that and go somewhere else, maybe.

John Rogers:

And I remember when we made London Perambulator, I think that’s what you said in the interview about Psychogeography when. I asked you about Psychogeography and you said, I prefer Nick’s term deep topography. And I think always in terms of that personal engagement with landscape and with topography deep topography is a lot more relevant. What Nick would say and has said quite robustly is that Nick, he would say if he was here, the really what he’s really interested in is insect life and plant life and, you know, in a way, you know, you can’t practice deep topography in the way that Nick does without being obsessed with what other people call weeds. You know, like for him, The Unofficial Countryside is almost like his seminal text, if you like. And, you know, Nick’s written extensively about Ant hills. You know, he would sit for an afternoon and study ants some of the things with crossovers where he will write about or think about or talk about, you know, a car accident that actually happened on the A41T But then he’ll write about from the point of view of a crow who observed it, I think a lot of it is about natural history.

Iain Sinclair:

When he did a piece for London City of Disappearances book I did It was almost classic in both senses of deep topography and psychogeography in that he’s determined to investigate buildings from an erased village that’s been lost to Heathrow Airport development. And he provokes a situation where police arrest him and it becomes the conflict becomes visible, the fault lines become visible. And he’s done that by an action. So essentially, one kind of story becomes another because he’s when he’s doing the first, it’s very much like you say, in the deep topography. He’s he’s looking at all of the natural life that’s been affected, all surviving in these areas and then the forces of outside that are challenging it and wiping it away. And he makes a great story out of that. And it’s very similar. Again, deep topography to Alan Moore’s Unearthing.

John Rogers:

Completely. I think Unearthing and also The Voice of the Fire is a great deep topography and imagined history for a very real location that draws on it, but also creates this whole other set of narratives.

Iain Sinclair:

There’s two basic traditions. You know, you’ve got a very politicized and philosophical French tradition, and you’ve got a more visionary, poetic English tradition that fuse, to a degree that they both aim to be to some degree, revolutionary and subversive.

John Rogers:

Yeah, that’s the answer to your question.

Iain Sinclair:

I think it’s the most intelligent discussion I’ve had on Psychogeography because, you know, it’s one of those ones that gets asked, what is it? Because I mean, it’s not an easy answer. Obviously, there are places we can go now to hear the full answer.

John Rogers:

There is a Radio Three essay on it, actually, that Ian Marchant made I think it was 2011, I did the interview at the new Stratford Westfield Center and Stuart Home’s in it you must be in it, can’t believe you wouldn’t be in it and in the end I think it’s Stewart Home or Will Self just says oh it’s just ‘walking with attitude’ which is what the show is called if you want to find it is called Walking with Attitude.

Iain Sinclair:

Yeah, I think that’s what it isn’t. Anymore, you know, that’s what it’s become. What if it’s walking without attitude?

The hacienda must be built

Ivan Chtcheglov quote, 'The Hacienda must be built'

“All cities are geological. You can’t take three steps without encountering ghosts bearing all the prestige of their legends. We move within a closed landscape whose landmarks constantly draw us toward the past. Certain shifting angles, certain receding perspectives, allow us to glimpse original conceptions of space, but this vision remains fragmentary. It must be sought in the magical locales of fairy tales and surrealist writings — castles, endless walls, little forgotten bars, mammoth caverns, casino mirrors.”

Ivan Chtcheglov, Formulary for a New Urbanism 1953

A note on psychogeography and the dérive

I recently came across an essay on ‘Situationists and Architecture’ by Peter Wollen in The New Left Review from 2001. I thought it was worth sharing these passages on psychogeography  and the dérive as it’s a subject I’m often asked to explain or define, so scholarly sources are always very welcome.

 

psychogeography

from Memoires by Guy Debord & Asgar Jorn 1959

 

“Guy Debord wrote the classic text on the ‘Theory of the Dérive’—usually translated as ‘drift’ or ‘drifting’—in December 1958, in the second number of Internationale Situationniste. He defines it as ‘a technique of transient passage through varied ambiences’. Note, again, the taste for transience and spontaneity. Debord’s basic idea is that this project of wandering through the city should be determined not by any preconceived plan, but by the attractions or discouraging counter-attractions of the city itself. It requires a ‘letting go’ of ‘the usual motives for movement and action’—we might almost say, a letting go of everyday identity. Debord seems to have been inspired in part by Paul-Henry Chombart de Lauwe’s study of Paris et l’agglomération parisienne, published in 1952; and particularly by its maps, which are frequently used as illustrations in the Situationist journal and in Debord’s own art works. He was especially struck by a map detailing all the movements made over a year by a student living in the 16th Arrondissement: ‘her itinerary delineates a small triangle, with no deviations, the three apexes of which are the School of Political Science, her residence and that of her piano teacher.’

Shocked by this rigid repetition of a fixed pattern of mobility, Debord conceived dérive as a way of creating completely new, unpredictable itineraries, dependent on chance and the spontaneous subjective impulses and reactions of the wanderer. The recourse to chance reminds us, unavoidably, of André Breton’s doctrine of ‘objective chance’ and above all of his great book, Nadja, which traces a series of just such aimless journeys through Paris, punctuated by a pattern of attraction and repulsion to certain buildings, or kinds of buildings, rather than others. Debord notes that this technique of dérive is, in a way, only necessary because his larger project of ‘psychogeography’ has not yet been sufficiently far developed. Psychogeography would make possible the creation of maps in which particular locations or regions had already been designated as favouring the arousal of one kind of affective or aesthetic response, so that a certain amount of pre-planning could take place. Meanwhile, chance was the best method. (This text, interestingly enough, was written just as John Cage was conducting his seminars on chance procedures at the School for Social Research in New York. Probably a coincidence.)

A dérive could take place over a few minutes or even a few days. Duration didn’t matter. Taxis could be used for rapid transport outside one’s usual environment. (One Situationist demand was for the abolition of private cars and their replacement by fleets of low-cost taxis.) As in Breton’s book, the dérive also implied the possibility of chance encounters, meetings with strangers. Debord even suggests that the subject of a dérive might be invited to visit a particular place at a particular time, with the expectation of meeting an unknown person, thus being forced to introduce themself to random passers-by in an effort to identify whether this was the person he or she was looking for. This was called the technique of the ‘possible rendezvous’. He also reveals a taste for straying in uncanny locations—‘slipping by night into houses due for demolition . . . wandering in subterranean catacombs forbidden to the public, etc.’ Here we see the dérive as a kind of dream journey, even an invitation to break taboos—or, perhaps, simply to enjoy what we might think of, in the architectural register, as the Gothick picturesque.

…from the start, psychogeography was bound up with the creation of situations; and the concept of situations was expanded, in time, to cover not just the city, but the whole of society, the totality of possibilities open in an unalienated community.”

PETER WOLLEN, New Left Review 8, March-April 2001

The radical tradition of urban walking – my article in the NewStatesman

radical urban walking

‘What both the interwar topographers and the situationists recognised was the transformative potential of large numbers of people regularly stepping outside the matrix, taking to the streets and walking, becoming active participants rather than passive spectators.’

Read the article here

Debunking Debord – Chris Gray Memorial Lecture

Last week I was invited to Housmans for the inaugural Christopher Gray Memorial Lecture given by Gray’s long-term friend and collaborator Charles Radcliffe.

It was fascinating to hear Radcliffe talk about heading off to Paris with Chris Gray to meet Guy Debord and join the Situationist International. He was disparaging about Debord, saying how square he was and didn’t understand the acid culture that was a significant force in 60’s London (Gray later authored The Acid Diaries). Debord’s intellectual achievements weren’t contested but more the manner of how he dealt with his allies and fellow travelers.

He then gave a pithy account of all the expulsions and exclusions from the SI instigated by Debord and how the Situationists never really seemed to do anything else. Radcliffe was in that select group of people who resigned.
It was a great evening and felt I learnt more about Debord and the SI than in the previous years of reading hagiographies of Debord and his cohorts.

On the way home I read Chris Gray’s introduction to his key book on the SI – Leaving the 20th Century. It seemed from the talk and from Gray’s text that the principle thinker on psychogeography wasn’t Debord by Ivan Chtcheglov. I imagine Debord couldn’t be bothered to walk around Paris all day from the sounds of it.

A passage from the book about the foundation of the SI also struck me:

‘On 28th July 1957, delegates from l’Internationale Lettriste, from the largely Scandinavian and German Movement pour un Bauhaus Imaginiste and from a dubious London Psychogeographical Committee, met at a formal congress at Coscio d’Arroscia in Italy and decided to amalgamate. L’Internationale Situationiste was born.’

Does this mean that this ‘dubious’ London Psychogeographical Committee was the first explicitly psychogeographical group?

If so makes it fitting that the practice and ideas of psychogeography were revived in London in the late 1980s/early 90’s by two men who were in the audience that night at Housmans – Fabian Tompsett and Stewart Home.

There is a video of the part of the event on the Housmans Youtube Channel

london

Chris Gray – Anarchist, writer and maverick Situationist – Obituary

Dick Pountain, The Guardian Wednesday 8 July 2009

In London in 1966, Chris Gray, who has died of cancer aged 66, teamed up with Charles Radcliffe, an anarchist blues aficionado, to produce Heatwave, a magazine blending radical politics with the nascent youth culture. They soon attracted the attention of the Situationist International (SI), in Paris.
The leading lights of the SI, founded in 1957, were the French theorist Guy Debord and the Belgian philosopher Raoul Vaneigem. A descendant of earlier 20th-century European avant gardes, the dadaists, surrealists and letterists, it added its own libertarian strain of Marxist politics. Its 15-year existence was hectic and expulsion-prone, but it achieved an influence on radical culture and politics – especially the May 1968 events in Paris – far beyond its tiny numbers. Gray was more attuned to the sensual post-surrealism of Vaneigem than Debord’s cerebral Hegelian Marxism, and he translated Vaneigem’s Banalités de Base (1962-63) as the pamphlet The Totality for Kids (1967), thus helping to introduce the SI’s ideas to British radicals.
English members Don Nicholson-Smith, Tim (TJ) Clark, Gray and Radcliffe parted company with the SI in 1967: the first three and others then assembled King Mob, a group named from a slogan daubed during London’s 1780 Gordon Riots, along with a magazine, King Mob Echo. Nicholson-Smith remembers King Mob as being composed of “ex-artists, ex-socialists and radicalised hippies” who were caught “between the dialectical certainties of Paris and the no-holds-barred, risk-everything example” of the New York group Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers, a “street gang with an analysis” founded by the painter Ben Morea and the poet Dan Georgakas.
What most distinguished King Mob from late 60s student revolutionaries was its sense of humour, displayed in stunts such as entering the toy department of Selfridges, in London’s Oxford Street, dressed as Santa Claus and giving away the toys to passing kids, or scrawling erudite graffiti around west London. King Mob participated in the March 1968 anti-Vietnam war protest in London – culminating outside the US embassy in Grosvenor Square – under a banner drawn from William Burroughs that proclaimed: “Storm the reality studio and retake the universe”.
King Mob had dispersed by 1970, and two years later Debord dissolved the SI. Gray turned away from politics, his parting act being his 1974 publication of a valedictory anthology of SI writings, Leaving the 20th Century: The Incomplete Work of the Situationist International.
Gray was born in Crosby, Liverpool, and his parents separated after his father returned from war service in Kashmir. Chris was raised by his grandmother until the age of 10. In 1952, his parents reunited and moved to Cornwall, sending him to Repton school in Derbyshire. He evaded a university education and in the late 1950s gravitated to London’s Soho, where from 1959 to 1961 he was to be found helping the poet and playwright Neil Oram run one of London’s first basement jazz cafes, Sam Widges, in D’Arblay Street. Then he travelled across the US with the film-maker Conrad Rooks, returning to London in 1965.
By the late 1970s Gray was spending much time in India, as a trekking guide in the Himalayas and a not uncritical follower of Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh (known after 1989 as “Osho”). Under the pen-name “Sam”, Chris published Life of Osho (1997) and The Acid (2009).
Charismatic, charming and perpetually amused, Gray was a romantic rebel in the Byronic mould. Clark remembers most his distinctive laugh – “a high-pitched, disbelieving, boyish cackle, full of delight in human folly. The kind of laugh one imagines Rochester or Rimbaud having. Chris was about as remote from the moralising puritanism of the British left as one could imagine.”
I first met Chris on the steps of an occupied London School of Economics in 1969 and that laugh changed my life, convincing me that mischief-making would be far more fun than staring at test tubes.
Towards the end of Leaving the 20th Century, Gray wrote that “Everyone’s life is a switch between changing oneself and changing the world. Surely they must somehow be the same thing and a dynamic balance is possible … I want to find it again – that quickening in oneself and in others, that sudden happiness and beauty.”
He is survived by a daughter, Maria, with former partner Brenda, and a son, Elian, with former partner Usha.
• Christopher Nelson Gray, activist and writer, born 22 May 1942; died 14 May 2009
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2009

london